The Golden Compass (release: Dec, 07) - based on a Philip Pullman novel

[AB]

I know I always harp on about how much of a fantasy fiction genius Philip Pullman is but I can't help it. He just is. His first film adaptation is released this December based on his first novel in His Dark Materials trilogy, The Northern Lights. For some reason the film has adapted the American book title and they have had to cut some of the controversial references and plot lines that focus on the church and God. Personally, I feel this is a great shame. Who cares if it offends some people, they're removing a very intricate and important element of the whole trilogy. I think he is great at altering the typical fantasy stereotypes and drawing you into the story. The Ice Bears are a great example. If you don;t manage to read the books you can at least watch the film to see what you make of it.

The trailer does look amazing and I'm sure they've moulded it into a very good piece of fantasy film.

Looking forward to it.

[AB]

Just found a good article on the new film on Timesonline. Click here to check it out.

[Darth Snarky]

The thing about movies made/released in America, is that the entertainment section is censored like crazy. If you look at the cabaret and satire in the Netherlands, and over there, there is a great difference.
Nevertheless, I look forward to seeing the movie, because my favourite actor stars in it and I'm a sucker for fantasy XD

[Lysmandor]

I realize that some people are going to say that it sucks, but I found that it followed fairly close to the book. The only thing that bugged me was the lack plot lines centering around the church(what are they going to do in the third movie?) and the place where it ended. I suppose that they couldn't possibly end it on such a cliffhanger note as the book ends, but still... The loss of the church and the insertion of the Magisterium was a shame, but there was so much controversy as it is even with the 'questionable' material removed. Why can't people take it for what it is- a story.

[AB]

I agree. It is a fantasy novel. You don;t see dwarfs being offended at the use computers to make the hobbits 'little' in LOTR. I know that's taking it a bit far but it's true. These are stories and, if they provoke controversy and discussion in the church, then that is surely a good thing as when else is religion and the church discussed in the media except in war and scandal. I also agree that where it ended didn't really follow the book and for people who haven;t read the book I can understand how they would be a little disappointed it just stopped - especially as the decision on whether to make any more was going to be based on the popularity of this one. Anyway, enough said I think. Great novels, watchable family film.

[Lysmandor]

It's rather sad how nothing can simply be taken as a story or a opinion any more, and everything must be "politically correct". I've actually heard someone protesting against Christmas and Santa Claus, because his "weight problems" might lead children to think that it's okay to be overweight. I agree, though, that it was a very watchable film.